RESQSHIP wins in court: Libya is not a place of safety!

Press release dated November 19, 2026:

 

POLITICAL BLOCKADE FAILS 

RESQSHIP wins in court: Libya is not a place of safety! 

 

The Civil Court of Agrigento (Italy) has ruled that the June 2025 detention of the sailing vessel NADIR, operated by the German search and rescue organisation RESQSHIP, was unlawful and has lifted it. Yesterday, Wednesday 18 November, the judge upheld the appeal lodged by RESQSHIP and the captain concerned, Friedhold Ulonska. In clearly worded reasoning, the court found that the captain had acted lawfully and that it is now a “well-established fact that the Libyan state cannot constitute a ‘place of safety’ for disembarkations.” 

On 7 June 2025, the Prefecture of Agrigento had detained NADIR for 20 days following the rescue of 112 people and opened proceedings to impose a fine. The allegations: NADIR’s had failed to report the distress case immediately to the Libyan and Tunisian authorities, and had headed for Lampedusa instead of Porto Empedocle, a port 22 hours’ away. Yesterday, the court rejected both accusations – and also ordered the Italian Ministry of the Interior and the Prefecture to pay the legal costs. 

The court makes it clear: Libya is not a place of safety! 

During the rescue operation, the captain had alerted the Maritime Rescue Coordination Centre in Rome and the flag state, Germany. He then tried unsuccessfully to reach the Rescue Coordination Centres in Tripoli (Libya) and Tunis (Tunisia). Although the Italian authorities had forwarded the distress alerts, the Libyan and Tunisian authorities remained “inactive”, according to the court. Citing the SAR conventions, the judge stated unequivocally that it is now a “well-established fact that the Libyan state cannot constitute a ‘place of safety’ for disembarkations.” 

Continuing to Sicily would have been unreasonable 

The second accusation did not stand up in court either. According to the judgment, only one port assignment was Lampedusa. Porto Empedocle had not been documented, nor would it have been a reasonable destination for the 112 people on board seeking protection. The court recognised allthe captain’s reasons for heading to the port of Lampedusa as part of discharging his duties in an emergency, and as entirely lawful. 

“It is astonishing that the courts have to explain maritime law to the Ministry of the Interior time and again: Libya is not a place of safety! Full stop. The fact that the Ministry and the Prefecture did not even appear in court shows what these detentions are really about. They are not about the law, but about harassment – and about keeping life-saving assistance away from people in distress at sea and preventing us from documenting the human rights violations in the Central Mediterranean.”
–– Friedhold Ulonska, Captain of NADIR 

 A signal beyond the individual case 

The Prefecture of Agrigento and the Ministry of the Interior had relied on the ‘Piantedosi Decree’ to justify the detention. Introduced in 2023, the decree undermines the application of the maritime and international legal framework for search and rescue at sea and has since formed the basis for numerous detentions. The Ministry and the Prefecture have now been ordered to bear the legal costs of around €5,000 themselves. And the significance of the ruling extends beyond the detention of NADIR: 

“The court makes it clear that the authorities cannot detain civilian rescue vessels as they please. Whoever orders a detention must also prove the accusations. Instructions to a captain are only binding if they are themselves compatible with international maritime law.”

–– Lucia Gennari, lawyer for RESQSHIP

–

“Every case won sets limits on arbitrary action by the authorities and strengthens the legal position of the entire civil fleet in the Central Mediterranean.”–– Giulia Crescini, lawyer for RESQSHIP

 

 

About RESQSHIP: 

Since 2021, RESQSHIP has been conducting search and monitoring missions in the central Mediterranean with the sailing vessel NADIR. In distress cases, the crews provide life-saving assistance, thereby fulfilling their obligation under international law. In this way, NADIR’s crews have already been able to support more than 14,500 people in distress at sea. 

 

Press contact: Merle Dammhayn
Email: presse@resqship.org
Phone: +39 331 4218860 

Further Articles

Somewhere in the Middle of the Mediterranean

Somewhere in the Middle of the Mediterranean

Letters to land from approximately 34° 38.5 N, 13° 22.5 E  Today we located 15 people in distress on a fiberglass boat with two 20-horsepower engines. A white dot on the horizon that seemed very far away instantly turned into a boat with 15 survivors on board, all...

read more
Fear, hope, and resistance in the (militarised) Mediterranean

Fear, hope, and resistance in the (militarised) Mediterranean

Navigating shipwrecks and interceptions by violent militias while people trying to reach Europe keep exercising their right to move. From ›letting people die‹ to the ›power to kill‹ In the last year, the presence of the so-called Libyan Coast Guard (scLYCG) in the...

read more
Scirocco Festival 2026: Solidarity Knows No Borders

Scirocco Festival 2026: Solidarity Knows No Borders

Newsletter from September 1, 2026: We’ve just wrapped up three days filled with music, dialogue, and acts of solidarity. This year’s second edition of the Scirocco Festival was far more than just an August weekend of concerts and a lively atmosphere. It was a space...

read more

Contact Us

RESQSHIP

Impressum

Resqship e.V. Osterrade 4, 21031 Hamburg
© 2024 RESQSHIP

Spendenkonto:

IBAN:   DE 18 4306 0967 2070 8145 00
BIC:   GENO DE M1 GLS
GLS Gemeinschaftsbank eG